The daily 'Who Are Ya?' game — name the mystery footballer from his teammates.
Guess the Player is a football guessing game where you identify a mystery footballer from the real players they lined up alongside. A new teammate is revealed after every wrong guess, so the more football you know, the faster you will crack it.
Suppose the hidden player is Robert Lewandowski. The first clue is Thomas Müller. That only tells you the mystery player was at Bayern Munich at some point after 2008, which leaves hundreds of options. You guess Arjen Robben, which is wrong, and the second clue appears: Mario Götze.
Now things tighten. Götze played for Dortmund and Bayern, so the mystery player could well be someone who also played for both. You guess Mats Hummels, which is wrong, and the third clue is Pedri. Someone who played with Müller, with Götze and with Pedri at Barcelona narrows to one name, and Lewandowski is solved in four.
Every teammate shown genuinely played in the same squad as the mystery player in at least one overlapping season. The clues are spread across his career rather than all coming from one club. The game takes one from each team in turn, starting with the biggest teams he played for, so the first clue usually points to the most famous chapter of his career and later clues fill in the rest.
The pool of mystery players is a few hundred well-known footballers, chosen so that a regular fan has a fair chance of knowing who each one played alongside.
The useful question is never "who played with this person?" but "who played with all of these people?". One clue is a club and an era. Two clues are an intersection, and the intersection is usually small. Before you guess, picture each teammate’s career as a set of club-and-years boxes and look for the box they share.
Not every clue is equally useful. A one-club player such as a long-serving captain pins you to a single club almost immediately. A well-travelled teammate who spent two seasons each at eight clubs tells you much less. International teammates are a strong nationality clue but say little about the club. When a clue is weak, it is often better to use the guess to rule out the most obvious name than to skip.
Three games here hide one player and give you different evidence. Guess the Footballer gives you the people around him. Career Path gives you his clubs in order. Football Contexto gives you nothing but a number for how close each guess is. Fans who remember squads tend to prefer this one, and fans who remember transfers usually prefer Career Path.